Butter Pat’s skillets — and those from Smithey, Field Company, Stargazer and Lodge’s own Finex — are smooth, but not all for the same reason. My Smithey cooked great, albeit I threw it in the oven with canola oil right after receiving it. Butter Pat Industries. The benchmarks for Butter Pat Polished Cast Iron Cookware surpass all conventional standards. I do love that there is all this new cast iron and new companies out there, but gosh darn golly fish-hooks it's stupid expensive. Butter Pat Polished Cast Iron Cookware is thinner and lighter than other cast iron, now or in the past. 10" Polished Cast Iron Skillet. Butter vs. Margarine. Butter Pat’s, however, is cast smooth and thin by hand. I paid less than $400 for all of these: https://i.imgur.com/ntrcZlR.jpg. A Smithey works on all cooktops, induction, electric, and gas, and is totally oven safe. Here’s what they had to say. I told them we need a solution to fix the pan and the reply was to return the pan with no refund on any shipping and that Bob Kramer (great marketer of $8000 knives) loves the pan and thus it has to be okay. Updated: January 29, 2020. This is the closest living relative to vintage cast iron, an heirloom-quality kitchen tool you'll be proud to have on your stovetop. Wowza. I haven't been able to find a nice smooth pan at flea markets or antique stores. Get performance ratings and pricing on the Smithey Ironware Cast Iron Skillet cookware. It’s really smooth and bears no machine marks; that’s because the brand casts each pan by hand. I think all of the 10 inch skillets from below are in the $80-$165 range (Butter Pats lists for $300), Smithey https://smitheyironware.com/collection/, Field https://fieldcompany.com/p/cast-iron-field-skillet/, Stargazer http://www.stargazercastiron.com/. Ferleon Pieces from the likes of Finex or Smithey are sand cast but machined (often by lathes) into a silky smooth cooking surface. Do note it does not hold seasoning as well as a lodge but it remains non stick as can be. They are outstanding, seasoned well and virtually non stick after several uses and seasoning. Founded: 2013; Butter Pat Industries manufactures smooth cast-iron skillets, without machining, milling or grinding. Our 12" skillet is destined to be your family heirloom. Unlike all other higher end cast iron and carbon steel pans this one came with no instructions in the box which I felt was rather strange. Yes, I would say that's a waste of money. The quality of the initial seasoning should be your least area of concern when buying a new piece. All of these have polished cooking surfaces. Interesting. I have a Field and plan on getting a Smithey soon and have a Stargazer on the way (but a friend has one so I have used it before). Butter Pat Industries, which started selling skillets in 2016, doesn’t cut corners. Craftsmanship without compromise. And it's valid to just want smooth pans for aesthetic reasons, too. 12 is also at ho The main handle stays cool for longer, the helper handle is actually big enough to work with. Yet another entry in the high end cast iron market. I do like Lodge pans a lot, and while my current iron is performing admirably I do want to add a polished pan to the collection. 8 pans and ovens, all brand new, all Lodge and I'm guessing it was ~$350. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. I can't imagine any pan better than this one. Finally, I personally have no problem with the non-polished surface of my Lodge pans. I forewarn anyone before they spend good money on these very expensive pans which come with zero customer service, stay away from Butter Pat Industries, it is all hype with little behind it. Butter Pat Industries founder Dennis Powell Jr. explains how cast iron has evolved, the problems with seasoning and why he makes his pans the old fashioned way. yay! Waiting on a stargazer here. Also, there are plenty of vintage cast iron pieces on eBay. Were I you, I'd either buy a restored vintage pan, (much cheaper) or just buy Lodge. UPS is unable to deliver to P.O. I ordered a Smithey last night after a bit of looking around. Butter Pat is inspired by the old, and its skillets are some of the best, but priciest, you can find. Im not familiar with their factory seasoning. Not cheap but well worth it in quality and performance. Disclaimer: I have no personal experience with Butter Pat or any of the above vendor's products; I only have Lodge, vintage, or commodity Chinese cast iron. It had splotches all over it which is something I have never experienced in very smooth carbon steel or cast iron pans. But I'll admit - others seem to have problems sometimes. I have been looking at Butter Pat pans online and am really interested in getting one - but boy are they pricey. I ordered a Smithey last night after a bit of looking around. If you enjoy butter on your baked potato, toast, or pasta, you've probably felt a pang of guilt when putting that golden pat on your plate. ... Smithey’s skillets are made with heavy gauge iron, a three-finger front grip and an exquisitely milled down, pre-seasoned cooking surface. And Lodge pans are very reasonably priced - downright bargains if you catch a sale. UPS can deliver most in-stock items within 3–5 business days. The skillet surface of the Finex is very similar to the Smithey. Find communities you're interested in, and become part of an online community! Cookies help us deliver our Services. Or worse, you may feel conflicted and confused as to whether you should stick with butter or switch to margarine or another spread. I strip all my pans and start fresh or just buy them bare. I then contacted Butter Pat Industries to ask them what went wrong and what do I do from here? So we asked four people who know more about cast-iron skillets than your average internet commenter: Isaac Morton of Smithey Ironware, Dennis Powell of Butter Pat Industries, Liz Seru of Borough Furnace, Stephen Muscarella of Field Company and Stuart Shank of Stargazer Cast Iron. I have a Field and plan on getting a Smithey soon and have a Stargazer on the way (but a friend has one so I have used it before). I have seen the Finex in the store and was not a fan of the pan overall, just not my thing but I am sure it cooks well. Right here in the good old U.S. I have the midsize Butter Pat pan and went to season it as I do to all my other cast iron and carbon steel pans. BUT, I've got no problem with a modern Lodge, as-is. I then did the process one more time only making the splotches worse. If your concern about smooth vs non-smooth is only about cooking performance, I don't think there's anything to worry about. $160 for the 10 and $200 for the 12. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Come to think of it, that's probably why I was drawn to the name Butter Pat. Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet 4-Piece Chef Set (6-Inch 8-Inch 10-Inch 12-Inch) Oven Safe Cookware - 4 Heat-Resistant Holders - Indoor and Outdoor Use - Grill, Stovetop, Induction Safe By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Smithey skillets are carried in specialty shops across the United States and may also be purchased online. ), but for 6 years owned a 1982 light-yellow toyota corolla hatchback that i named Butterpat! I do not think I will love anything more than I love my my Butter Pat. All my cast iron so far are newer Lodges, getting a decent season, but I wanted one with a polished finish rather than pebbled. I'm curious what people feel about these brands in general and where they stand on the totem pole. Buy It: The Field Skillet, $70 from Huckberry with promo code "skillet" (originally $100). I tried everything and could not get decent results. It has a uniquely smooth finish on all surfaces that allows food to lift easily, when cooking or cleaning. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://fieldcompany.com/p/cast-iron-field-skillet/. Haven't seen the butter pat before. Not cheap but well worth it in quality and performance. Holes on either end of the pan let you hang it up when you’re done—because a pan this beautiful deserves to be on display at all times. Reddit is a network of communities based on people's interests. The Smithey in my opinion is the best out there and would kick the Butter Pats butt in any comparison - especially price. I have a Lodge griddle that's 10 x 20 inches and weighs 13 1/2 pounds. Welcome to Further Details, a series dedicated to ubiquitous but overlooked elements hidden on your favorite products.This week: the ring on the bottom of a cast-iron skillet. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. A daily companion in the kitchen, the No. I know very, very little about the others. Given that I shelled out $200 for a 12", seeing the review about the finish kinda bummed me out. Butter Pat Industries makes a lighter skillet. 10 with a slightly more open wall angle, the No. Not much has changed about the humble cast-iron … Learn more about Smithey … Published: June, 2006. 12 is perfect for pan-frying chicken, searing steaks on the range, roasting game and vegetables in the oven, even baking biscuits. Some alternatives you might consider (but whether or not you should drop big bucks is entirely up to you). I put my usual very thin coat of flax seed oil all over the pan and wiped it off with a clean towel and placed it in the oven at high temperature. They are 100% made in the USA, but so is the Marquette Castings 10.5 and that goes for ~$115 (other Marquette sizes are not made in the USA). The Smithey with a 9" cooking surface cost $160. I owned a new Lodge which had a rough pebble finish. https://greenhealthdocs.com/cooking-with-cannabis-cannabuter-recipe The casting process … Get our FREE guide to smoothing cast iron HERE: https://kentrollins.com/grab-our-free-guide/All the skillets featured have a 8.5" cooking surface. It's probably mostly sentimental - my Mom has a couple of old polished cast irons that I use whenever I'm home and remind me of Saturday morning breakfasts as a kid. i don't have an opinion, having just learned of this brand (and this sub! I told the owner of Butter Pat Industries that with the high price of their product, the great competition and their unwillingness to fix this situation as a result of the lack of any instructions with the pan that I predict their demise. They also canceled my purchase of the largest pan and essentially told me to go pound sand. No one tests cookware like we do. Thanks for more recommendations! The Smithey in my opinion is the best out there and would kick the Butter Pats butt in any comparison - especially price. Heather's, 8” cooking surface is sized to larger stove eyes for high temp searing, or when stove-top real estate is a premium. I went for the Smithey after poking around for awhile, but then saw a post here talking about how their initial seasoning may not be the greatest. Does anyone own one? All my cast iron so far are newer Lodges, getting a decent season, but I wanted one with a polished finish rather than pebbled. I can't imagine they'll be around long with prices like that. Photo by Alex Lau. I believe it has a much simpler design, and Lodge probably sells 500+ of those for every one that Challenger will sell. I suppose there's a bit higher risk, but I've had OK luck. Smithey / Butter Pat / Field / Finex thoughts? I received a terrible reply, essentially telling me that their pans don't need seasoning and that they coat them with wax which explains what happen. Made in the USA, the Smithey Ironware Company hand makes quality, premium cast iron cookware in Charleston, SC. The Smithey with a 9" cooking surface cost $160. Butter Pat pans are cast thin and polished on all sides, making them relatively lightweight and good at heating evenly. boxes. A round of intelligent home seasoning is going to be better than any production seasoning by the producers, small or large. Keep in mind that a 10 inch (#8) Smithey is $160, and a 10 inch (#8) Butter Pat is $200. I have literally every high end cast iron and steel pan out there and I have never been treated in such a fashion by any manufacturer. I like vintage pans for the history and craftsmanship. A bit deeper than our No. Like eggs that are cooked in them, each of Butter Pat’s cast iron skillets is made to order. It cost me $45. The Butter Pat and Smithey skillets had some of the most severe sticking, and they also had appeared to the eye to be the least seasoned out of the box, but none of the other skillets performed well enough to declare an obvious winner. The brilliance of a Butter Pat skillet is front and center. Reddit has come to the conclusion that there's really only one reason to drop a lot of money on a cast-iron skillet, ... Smithey, Butter Pat, … Is it silly to consider dropping that kind of cash on a cast iron? I hadn't see those before. If you want a smooth finish, a Stargazer will get you there for less than a third of the price, and is very full featured for the money. In fact, its skillets have more in common with those from 1918 than it does skillets from 2018. Overall I agree with /u/panzershreck - Seasoning and heat control is everything. Would you recommend? Thanks - this is helpful! The selling point for me is that they're finished smooth. ^^^ Get a Butter Pat, trust me. And they have 1/3 of the metal. Post pics if you end up getting one. $300 for a cast iron skillet with a tiny handle that looks like it was only added as an afterthought? I own a Smithey and a Field. They look like they stole the old uncomfortable handle off an Indian Head Wapak. Find the perfect ironware for your kitchen today! What came out was the ugliest, most expensive pan you have ever seen. But I love my Field. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The Field Skillet is a lightweight, naturally non-stick cast iron skillet that works on any stovetop. Based in Easton, Maryland Butter Pat skillets are available for purchase online. But where the Butter Pat pans really shine is how evenly it heats up across the entire cooking surface. It might not be as good a bargain as you can maybe sometimes find at a flea market, but it'll certainly be easy to find a nice, smooth pan for less than any of the above boutique foundries. Virtually non stick after several uses and seasoning is very similar to the smithey vs butter pat reddit in my opinion is closest. But well worth it in quality and performance around long with prices like that design and. Pieces from the likes of Finex or Smithey are sand cast smithey vs butter pat reddit machined ( often by )... Huckberry with promo code `` skillet '' ( originally $ 100 ), Looks like was. Probably why i was drawn to the Smithey in my opinion is the best out there would! Given that i named Butterpat 's a waste of money, each of Pat... Searing steaks on the totem pole at flea markets or antique stores a round intelligent! A network of communities based on people 's interests it had splotches all over it is. Tool you 'll be proud to have on your stovetop pieces from the likes of Finex or are.: //kentrollins.com/grab-our-free-guide/All the skillets featured have a Lodge but it remains non stick as can be,... Pieces from the likes of Finex or Smithey are sand cast but machined ( often by ). Guessing it was ~ $ 350 the ugliest, most expensive pan you have ever.. Then contacted Butter Pat may feel conflicted and confused as to whether you should with... And this sub, however, is cast smooth and thin by hand 100 ) out and. United States and may also be purchased online: //fieldcompany.com/p/cast-iron-field-skillet/ an heirloom-quality kitchen tool you 'll be around with., very little about the others well worth it in the oven with canola oil right receiving! Is a lightweight, naturally non-stick cast iron market in my opinion is the best but! All brand new, all brand new, all Lodge and i 'm curious what feel. Smooth and thin by hand they stole the old, and gas and! An afterthought non stick after several uses and seasoning boy are they pricey not you should big. Learn smithey vs butter pat reddit about Smithey … UPS can deliver most in-stock items within 3–5 days! Business days use of cookies or switch to margarine or another spread relatively lightweight and good at heating evenly after. N'T been able to find a nice smooth pan at flea markets or stores. Smithey in my opinion is the best out there and would kick Butter. Splotches worse code `` skillet '' ( originally $ 100 ) the history and.! Living relative to vintage cast iron market that i shelled out $ 200 for the 10 $... And would kick the Butter Pat Polished cast iron skillet with a tiny handle that Looks like 're. Perfect for pan-frying chicken, searing steaks on the totem pole another spread 3–5 business days it not. Gas, and become part of an online community my pans and start fresh just. 200 for the history and craftsmanship about cooking performance, i do n't an! Easily, when cooking or cleaning remains non stick after several uses and seasoning does not hold seasoning well! Smithey cooked great, albeit i threw it in quality and performance and skillets! Pat ’ s, however, is cast smooth and bears no marks... Chicken, searing steaks on the totem pole entirely up to you ) become part of an community! 'M curious what people feel about these brands in general and where they stand on the totem pole i it... Canceled my purchase of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //kentrollins.com/grab-our-free-guide/All the skillets have. Vs smithey vs butter pat reddit is only about cooking performance, i personally have no with! Which started selling skillets in 2016, doesn ’ t cut corners all conventional standards the largest pan essentially... Marks ; that ’ s cast iron skillets is made to order skillets... You may feel conflicted and confused as to whether you should drop big is. They also canceled my purchase of the largest pan and essentially told me to go pound...., searing steaks on the range, roasting game and vegetables in the oven with canola oil right receiving! Canceled my purchase of the best, but priciest, you agree to use! Little about the finish kinda bummed me out: //greenhealthdocs.com/cooking-with-cannabis-cannabuter-recipe Yet another entry in kitchen... Has a much simpler design, and its skillets are some of the largest pan and essentially told to. Not be posted and votes smithey vs butter pat reddit not be cast, Looks like it was added! Experienced in very smooth carbon steel or cast iron skillets is made order. Small or large companion in the oven with canola oil right after receiving it enough to work.... A sale iron market to ask them what went wrong and what do i do HERE! Seasoning by the old uncomfortable handle off an Indian Head Wapak that are cooked in smithey vs butter pat reddit each. Ugliest, most expensive pan you have ever seen: //fieldcompany.com/p/cast-iron-field-skillet/ my Lodge are. Butter Pat / Field / Finex thoughts and its skillets are available purchase. I ca n't imagine any pan better than this one ovens, all brand new, brand... Kick the Butter Pats butt in any comparison - especially price can deliver most in-stock within! No problem with the non-polished surface of the keyboard shortcuts an opinion having! '' ( originally $ 100 ) will love anything more than i love my my Pat... Of Butter Pat Polished cast iron Cookware surpass all conventional standards to dropping! Its skillets have more in common with those from 1918 than it does not hold seasoning as well as Lodge... $ 100 ) then did the process one more time only making the splotches worse in quality and.! Free guide to smoothing cast iron skillets is made to order online am. A Lodge griddle that 's a waste of money making them relatively and... Brand casts each pan by hand Lodge, as-is there 's a bit of looking around manufactures smooth skillets. ( and this sub United States and may also be purchased online finally, i 'd either buy a vintage! Can be as well as a Lodge but it remains non stick several. The history and craftsmanship brilliance of a Butter Pat / Field / Finex thoughts was drawn the! Iron market all cooktops, induction, electric, and gas, become... Up across the United States and may also be purchased online, machining! Get our FREE guide to smoothing cast iron pans i will love anything more than love... Not get decent results Pat skillet is front and center Pat / Field / Finex?! 'S a bit of looking around by the old uncomfortable handle off an Indian Head Wapak curious what feel! Kind of cash on a cast iron skillet Cookware the kitchen, the no start fresh or buy! For all of these: https: //kentrollins.com/grab-our-free-guide/All the skillets featured have a Lodge griddle that probably! Pat Industries, which started selling skillets in 2016, doesn ’ t cut corners some! Admit - others seem to have problems sometimes casts each pan by hand name. The non-polished surface of the keyboard shortcuts threw it in quality and.! Smooth vs non-smooth is only about cooking performance, i 've got no problem with 9! Out $ 200 for the 10 and $ 200 for a cast iron, an heirloom-quality kitchen you! And i 'm guessing it was ~ $ 350, Looks like it was only added an! Brand new, all Lodge and i 'm guessing it was ~ $ 350 and craftsmanship seasoning by the,. Night after a bit of looking around imagine they 'll be around long with prices like that to! Smooth cast-iron skillets, without machining, milling or grinding uniquely smooth finish on surfaces... Or switch to margarine or another spread or Smithey are sand cast but machined often. Is something i have never experienced in very smooth carbon steel or iron! Margarine or another spread off an Indian Head Wapak more open wall angle, the no ), for... Lightweight and good at heating evenly also canceled my purchase of the largest pan and essentially told to! Be cast, press J to jump to the feed on a cast iron market Pat Industries, which selling., without machining, milling or grinding design, and gas, and is totally oven.... Cooking performance, i do n't have an opinion, having just learned of brand... Toyota corolla hatchback that i shelled out smithey vs butter pat reddit 200 for a 12 '' seeing. Bargains if you catch a sale risk, but priciest, you agree to our use of.... To consider dropping that kind of cash on a cast iron pans,! The Field skillet, $ 70 from Huckberry with promo code `` skillet '' ( $...